Bad Output / Poor Generation Quality (Mega Thread)
Shane
I'm consolidating all the 'bad output' posts together. This will be a lot easier for the devs to look into and potentially pick up more useful patterns of complaints and issues with the output.
Reference note to everyone:
The existing Udio models do not change in their output. They have not been worked upon or changed. I hope this is understood but I recognise that many users will still argue or say otherwise, this however can be demonstrated very clearly with seed output consistency, so we won't be getting into this debate or going down this rabbit hole with anyone as it's a waste of time*
The things and issues that are brought up here are things that will be looked into and worked towards improving in future models, not the existing ones. Lets look towards the future and hopefully the output should always keep improving with the next upcoming model updates. Nothing is garaunteed though, for how much and in what way things will get improved or not. Given the nature of GenAI it can be rather difficult to completely predict or control things in a precise manner.
*I say this but it is not 100% correct as there was a minor seed change on the 31st October. Which breaks full seed consistency to before that time but should not have affected the quality of output in any noticeable way and there should also still be some degree of seed consistency too. This is the only noticeable change that has been made to existing models though for a long time.
Shane
Merged in a post:
Song ends too soon ignoring the extension type and the clip start
Paco Barbas
Clip start and extension types are doing nothing. The model seems to be obsessed with ending the songs as soon as it can. It doesn't matter where you put the clip start, and that the extension type is not outro, it generates an outro anyways. It's happening a lot.
Shane
Merged in a post:
Extension has poor sync - wrong beginning or end
Ken Park
Sync not working with extension: Many times, the additional extension does not come with correct begin and ending by which it becomes useless, and once it were like that, whole song becomes out of sync.
Shane
Merged in a post:
WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO UDIO?
N
Nar Baal
A couple of months ago I stopped using Udio, because I felt that it was getting harder and harder to get the results I was looking for. And I thought that if I let some time pass when I came back again I would find an improved and better Udio,... but my goodness, what has happened? I don't know if this is a joke or a social experiment, but the outputs delivered are extremely strange, chaotic and sometimes even terrifying. It is the first time that a sound has provoked a feeling of fear and terror in me!!! All thousands of light years away from the requested prompt!!! This has happened to me exactly the same on different days, I really think that maybe it is a joke or experiment that I don't know, or that the creators of Udio have really lost their minds, or that I am in an alternative universe that I don't understand!!! What is clear and obvious to me is that I have thrown my money in the trash!
Shane
Merged in a post:
It most definitely is changing the output
Jerry Peters
You can show me all the seeds you want. Just about overnight all vocals became a chorus of obnoxious men with colds. I will not be renewing my membership.
Shane
Merged in a post:
Geberates lyrics when in instrumental mode
Christian Falk
Every beat i make, instrumental checked, I get lyrics on the songs...
Shane
Merged in a post:
Lyrics despite instrumental mode
Uli Reyka
If the Lyrics Timing function is still activated by mistake in Instrumental mode, Model 1.5 hallucinates and outputs gibberish lyrics. It would be helpful if either Instrumental would ignore the function (override) or a warning message could be displayed for the user, as it is easy to forget this setting when you are fully occupied with other things.
Thank you very much for the Extra-Credits Christmas present. I wish the entire Udio team a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year!
Shane
Merged in a post:
Hello I have noticed that in the past few months it's getting to the point where I can't get a single decent song out of it I don't know what you guys changed but it is dramatically worse and I don't mean that to be rude that's just my feedback I'm going to be at Suno until you guys fix it I guess
Brandon Furek
Shane
Merged in a post:
New UI has completely ruined it
Now, from the second generation onwards, the songs are actually ruined. The first generation is great, the second is catastrophic, and from the third generation onwards, the songs are basically ended. What are you actually doing wrong???????Look at Suno, they can do it, but you can't! You are miles behind! I'm just wondering why? Udio started perfectly but fell back so badly. Is that what you want? Seriously, do you want this?
Shane
The UI changes have nothing to do with model. And the model hasn't changed at all. But I'll move this into the bad model output mega thread for the devs to look into
Shane
Merged in a post:
Bug: Incoherence in Audio Generation with Greek Lyrics
Kostantin Ts
When Greek lyrics are placed in the lyrics box, the generated songs often turn out to be incoherent, sounding as if they’re sung in a non-existent language.
Load More
→